Real Madrid or AC Milan

Comparing Liverpool’s 2005 opponents to 2018’s

It’s just over two weeks until the Champions League Final in Kiev and many pundits have been weighing up Liverpool’s chances against the all powerful Real Madrid.  The Spanish giants are aiming for a third straight title and a fourth win in five seasons.  This fact alone makes Liverpool’s task all the more daunting.  However Real are not our first intimidating finalists in this competition.  It’s interesting, as we once again go in as the underdogs, to compare this Real team, to the glitzy AC Milan side we triumphed over as massive underdogs thirteen years ago.

True All Stars

Jamie Carragher rightfully revered the opponents Liverpool faced at the Ataturk Stadium on 25th May 2005 in his autobiography.   Taken from the purely simplistic argument, one to eleven they weren’t just better than us, they were in a different league.

A team littered with great players fielded the evergreen Paulo Maldini for his sixth European Cup final, alongside a back four which consisted of Cafu, Jaap Stam and Nesta. They must have been nervous to face an attacking duo of Harry Kewell and Milan Baros.  In front of this defensive rearguard, were Andrea Pirlo, Kaka, Shevchenko, Crespo, Gatusso and Seedorf.  If you were picking a world XI at that point in time, you wouldn’t go far wrong with that entire midfield and attacking contingent.

They looked tailor made for success and played football with a style of sophistication worthy of some of the great AC Milan sides down the years.  Kaka was in his prime and operated in a midfield paring with Pirlo which would have given Iniesta and Xavi a run for their money.

That first half display in Istanbul was a truly bruising and humbling affair.  Our back four was sliced open at will and at one point it looked as though it might get truly embarrassing. Masterminded by Carlo Ancelotti, AC were breezing past us in silky smooth attack waves that left us reeling.


We should still thank our lucky stars for Steven Gerrard’s gallantry that night; in his heroics where the seeds of AC Milan’s downfall.  Legends will forever be spun about their team partying at halftime, believing they had it in the bag. This is a detail strenuously denied by their camp, but it is fair to say that our fighting spirit in that second half flurry did something to their psyche.

Most sides would be terrified of losing by five or six, but Liverpool, inspired by Gerrard approaching his ferocious and powerful best, came at them and AC somehow collapsed.  Perhaps overconfidence was their undoing, we will never know, but football is a strange game.  Momentum can switch in a second, and your team must be mentally strong.  By the time the final whistle went and extra time beckoned, the AC Milan players looked shell-shocked, their slickness had disappeared and Liverpool had levelled the playing field against a vastly superior side.

A different beast

It truly is splitting hairs to try identifying weakness in that AC Milan side.  Furthermore, they returned to final again and got revenge against us in 2007, with a truly professional and mentally strong performance given the emotion of that night in Athens.

Real Madrid on the other hand, if we’re talking about personnel on paper, aren’t anywhere near the quality of that AC Milan side.  When all fit and firing, Bale, Ronaldo, Benzema, Isco et al are a truly world class unit, with Ronaldo still showing the same hunger and quality at thirty-three, which have made him one of the true sporting greats of his generation.

Recently however they have not all been fit and firing.  They remain third in the league with goals-against tally of forty-two. Adding to their woes; Ronaldo has caused panic of an injury niggle picked up in El Clasico. It is odd then, that despite all of this, they still present, a greater threat than that Milan side of 2005.

As discussed in this site’s article after their semi-final victory over Bayern, this is a team that simply knows how to win The Champions League.  The aforementioned players, plus the likes of Marcelo and Ramos have all come through a glorious sequence of success in the Champions League.

At their core, they have retained these veterans of recent triumphs.  Its in their DNA. Liverpool must be wary of their opponents upping their game in Kiev as the look to emulate the Real stars of the 1950s. No doubt our pace and press will cause them some discomfort on the night, but Real will be ruthless, as they were against Bayern in the last round.  They can dig deep, feeding off the doubters and skeptics.  Zidane went through the same as player, when his Galaticos side was forever ducking and diving the lash of Spain’s relentless media critics, no doubt this experience has been invaluable as a manger.

Had that AC Milan side come into Istanbul off the back of one or two previous Champions League wins, we may not have got a glove on them.  Such was their quality; they only lacked that know-how that Real Madrid has earned through final victories against Atletico and Juventus.

It is always better to face a raw, mentally unprepared but gifted side, then a similarly gifted, mechanically efficient one, even if some of their players are not in their prime.  Liverpool will always be dangerous under Klopp and especially with that front three firing on all cylinders, but we must wary of a dangerous beast backed into a corner.  They will have no sentiment for another underdog story in the Champions League as they look to wrap up number thirteen.


  1. The article was summed up by this line.
    “No doubt our pace and press will cause them some discomfort on the night, but Real will be ruthless, as they were against Bayern in the last round.”
    One, our pace and press doesn’t cause some discomfort. It causes some blackout, according to some accomplished player. We aren’t the top scorers in the tournament for nothing. And RM won’t sit back and absorb us and then counter. If they could do that, I would really be worried.
    Two, Real weren’t ‘ruthless’ against Bayern. Bayern were generous in not being able to hit a barn door. Had they taken their chances, we may have well been looking at a different final lineup. But they didn’t. And here we are. Do you want to bet that we are going to be that generous? Especially with the front three being in the murderous mood that they have been! Sure, we should be wary of the strength they have in attack. But they should be even more worried about the gegenpress and the counter attacks we transit in in a matter of seconds. And we should be even more worried about grown up men putting in performances worthy of an Oscar by diving around and flopping around as if they have been shot and demanding fouls and cards.


    1. I don’t for one minute doubt our ability going forward. Our front free are amongst the best in the world. My article was just a note on how Real are veterans. It was also a comparison between the AC side in 05 and the current team we have now.

      Madrid were ruthless in the semis, they had a handful of chances in two legs and scored 4 times from 7 shots on targets, Bayern’s poor finishing as you rightly highlight, doesn’t mean Real were not ruthless.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s